Deborah Sherfield Bess was 38-years old when she was found dead of a gunshot wound on August 19th, 1986 at her Richland Road home.
Investigators at the time ruled her death a suicide, but last May Cold Case Detective Lieutenant Bill Sharp and Sergeant Dan Goodwin received new information about the circumstances of her death. After a lengthy investigation, Goodwin presented their findings to the Rutherford County grand jury who indicted Jewell Moses Bess for first-degree murder of his second wife. Bess is expected to be in Circuit Court April 13.
Sheriff's Cold Case Detectives Sharp and Goodwin give an overview of how they received new evidence after a quarter of a century . . .
63-year old Moses Bess (RCSO mugshot, left) was serving a 15-year prison sentence after pleading guilty in 1998 to four counts of child rape. He will complete that sentence this coming September.
Deborah Hulett Bess' Family Notified
“The children are very happy to hear about the indictment,” Goodwin said. “One daughter I just spoke to was weeping.”
7th Cold Case Solved
This is the seventh cold case solved by the unit since it was created in 2000.
Sheriff Robert Arnold said he was pleased by the indictment against Bess.
Sharp and Goodwin spend long hours investigating the cases and obtaining enough evidence prosecute the case for “justice for the family of the victim,” the sheriff said.
“When talking to victims’ families, they’re always very appreciative of the hard work of Lt. Sharp and Sgt. Goodwin to not let these cases go unsolved or unpunished,” Arnold said.
As part of an investigation, Goodwin said the Cold Case detectives try to determine what the victims did in their last hours of their lives.
“We found witnesses who had new information,” Goodwin said.
Sharp said after receiving information about Deborah Bess’ death, he and Goodwin questioned family members, neighbors, friends and associates of the wife and husband.
“During the investigation, we were able to establish the last known actions of Deborah Sherfield Bess,” Sharp said. “We’ve interviewed Mr. Bess on different occasions in the penitentiary at the Department of Correction’s Turney Center in Only, Tennessee.”
They reviewed the case file, crime scene photographs, witnesses’ statements and reports and discussed the case at length with District Attorney Bill Whitesell and Assistant District Attorney Paul Newman before presenting the case to the grand jury.
Bess was served the indictment. He was transferred from the Turney Center to the Rutherford County Adult Detention Center.
The Cold Case unit solved six unsolved murders and one kidnapping since it was founded. Four defendants charged with murder were convicted while trials are pending against two defendants.
Also, detectives assigned to the Criminal Investigations Division, who work all types of cases, solved an unsolved murder from 1982. Two people are serving life sentences while a third person is serving a 20-year prison sentence.
“We’re still actively working three cold case homicides right now,” Goodwin said.
RCSO Cold Cases solved
1. Victim Laura Salmon, 18, an MTSU student, was fatally beaten with rocks May 31, 1984. Her body was found off Twin Oak Drive. Salmon’s former boyfriend, David Kyle Gilley, was charged with first-degree murder Nov. 13, 2001. He was convicted of first-degree murder Aug. 4, 2006. He is serving a life sentence.
2. Victim Errastus “Gene” Stump, 32, of Smyrna, died from a gunshot wound to his head about March 29, 1982. His decomposing body was found April 28, 1982 off South Lamar Road. Suspect Randy Ray McFarlane was charged with first-degree murder of Stump, his co-worker, April 30, 2008. He was convicted of first-degree murder in January 2009 and is serving a life sentence.
3. Victim Marjorie Ewing, 24, of Rutherford County, was murdered on or about Dec. 27, 1980. Her remains were found March 23, 1981, at Stones River National Battlefield. Husband Charles B. Ewing was charged with his wife’s murder July 8, 2009. He pleaded guilty to first-degree murder in August 2009. He is serving a 40-year prison sentence.
4. Siblings Christi and Bobby Baskin were taken from Rutherford County by their maternal grandparents, Marvin and Sandra Maple March 1, 1989. Marvin Maple was arrested Feb. 2, 2009 in San Jose, Calif. His wife died in 2005. He pleaded guilty to two counts of custodial interference and placed on probation.
5. Jorja L. Walter, 30, of Rutherford County, died after being shot once in the head April 14, 1979 at her Manson Pike home. Roommate Christel Ann Perkins of Wellington Place was charged with first-degree murder in November 2010. She is awaiting trial.
6. Rhonda Sue Bailey’s body was found May 5, 1994 in a creek bed off state Route 99 (New Salem Highway). Bailey, 29, of Paulding County, Ga., drowned. David Wayne Newcomb, 45, of Cookeville entered a no contest plea to second-degree murder of Bailey. He was sentenced to 15 years in prison.
7. Deborah Sherfield Bess, 38, of Richland Road, died of a gunshot wound Aug. 19, 1986 at her home. Her husband, Jewell Moses Bess, 63, was indicted in March 2012 for first-degree murder of his second wife.
Also, Criminal Investigations Division Detective Sgt. Mark DiNardo and Detective Jim Tramel solved a 1982 murder case in 2007.
8. Lynn Orrand’s body was found Jan. 16, 1982 off Richland-Richardson Road. He was shot while hunting at his in-law’s property. His brother-in-law, Kevin Patterson, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder of Orrand and is serving a 25-year prison sentence. Orrand’s widow, Candance Bush, and her second husband, Gary Bush, were convicted of first-degree murder. The Bushes are serving life sentences.
